Penistaja Arroyo is a stream located in Sandoval County, New Mexico. It appears on the Ojo Encino Mesa USGS 7.5-minute topographic quadrangle. The elevation at this location is approximately 6,604.17 feet (2,012.95 m) above sea level. The nearest populated place is Ojo Encino, approximately 3.3 miles to the NNW.